Small suburban church needs new logo

This is what Good Shepherd Lutheran Church and Preschool was looking for in their logo design

We are a small Lutheran church located in Vancouver, WA called Good Shepherd Lutheran Church. We have a few different logos in use and no defined brand in place. We are looking to take our communications (both inward and outward) to the next level, beginning with a new logo that will eventually be used for print, a new website, media, t-shirts, publications, etc. We are looking for a logo that is easy to reproduce and display. We also have a preschool within our church which is a ministry of the church. I've attached a file that explains our core values. It is a rich document that is a lot to digest, but felt some may get a better sense of our culture from this document. Otherwise, some key words we have for inspiration are:
Outreach, community, believers, open, purpose, nostalgic, contemporary, educate, family, forward thinking, relational. Read more