Hello Matt
Thank you for the invitation.
I have a few questions before I commence.
How 25 "designers" rushed of 54 ideas to pass off as "designs" - with so little information is fascinating.

First - 6 different words means 6 different designs.
We need a Clear Message you want to send out and Stick With It:
"Best of" without saying what - can be left off the list.
"Super Service" - deserves no thought - can be left off the list.
The rest have to have a "meaning" - as in:
Excellence IN XYZ
Top Rated FOR XYZ
Premier Marine Pro ?? at what Rescue? Re-Build? Tax Evasion? Quality of Service and After-Service?
Elite Service IN THE XYZ (No-no. Every one does "Service". That is what they are getting paid to do. Getting an award for that is like getting a prize for just showing up at thre race)
Super Service - No - See Above
Best of - No. Marketing jargon

Colors?
A Logo is a logo - An award could have your company name in it.
But it needs more.
I will find 15 different Award designs on google in under 10 seconds
But ONLY TWO will make the grade. For me
And you will hate both of them.
You should provide something as guidance.

I can generate 45 awards concept designs in 45 minutes, for $0.00
But then you will have to buy my drinks ))

I look forward to a clarification in your post.
Many Thanks for the offer.

Franco

Hello Matt,
Thanks for invitation to your project,
you can tell me it is a single badge design or several badges if this is the case you can increase the project price in a way that it is adequate to the need and so that it motivates me to work calmly,

Hello! Please review my design.